← Tehiru
⇗ open this live, in the app →
idea
⭐⭐ It does not say ALL these
correspondences
nature
David's rung is Psalm 15, and the psalm ends: "he who does these things shall never be moved."
When Rabban Gamliel reached that verse he wept. Surely only one who does all of them is secure — and who does all of them?
The Sages answered him from the grammar. "Is it written, he who does ALL these? He who does these is written — even one of them."
And they proved it the way the Gemara proves things, from a verse where the same construction must mean one: Leviticus 18:24, "do not defile yourselves by any of these" — where nobody imagines a person is only defiled by committing the whole list.
⭐⭐⭐ So the passage that supplies the biggest number in Judaism ends by insisting that one is not nothing. That is why this app fires its celebration on the FIRST entry a reader opens and not the six hundred and thirteenth. A celebration held back until the end would teach the opposite of the sentence it is quoting.
⚠ It is a consolation and not a licence, and the Gemara does not pretend otherwise. Nobody on the page says to stop at one.
threads (2)
⇗ walk this live in Tehiru →